Now being the oldest in the business; Filmfare still has some respect in Bollywood and I particularly like it for Saif and SRK. Yes, they often kick some serious ass while hosting it and this year was no exception.
This post is not here to dissect each and every award offered at Filmfare this year, what particularly striking is an Award for Best Story\Screenplay and Dialogue...all three went to 3 Idiots.
I hardly ....hardly miss any movies to watch but somehow 3 idiots just did not happen to me. I watched it after 2 months, yeah it is a GOOD and well made movie. Quite entertaining and full on timepass but that's it. What surprised me is the all hoopla around the movie.
Some of my friends said that it's the best movie ever made in India....sorry but that's just too much.
First and foremost...it's 5 Point Someone and I think they did not give the due credit for the author. And top of that Raju Hirani accepted the best story award for it...cmmon Raju, have some respect!!!!
The centre idea, premises and all twists and turns are straight out of the book. And frankly the part added for the movie is either too lame or too melodramatic. The otherwise believable characters from the book becomes HEROS in movie, no complaint about it...but when throughout the movie; you cry for Innovation and originality, have some in your movie too....
3 idiots is too pretentious....most of the fun part runs on shoulder of 5 point someone...when it isn't it's either going on Munnabhai way or Taare Zameen Par way....when it's neither ...it's simply boring.
ViruS character is awesome but it's largely an enhancement of Raju Hirani's very own J(dot) Asthana from Munnabhai MBBS. Ryan from the book becomes Rancho here and loses it's charm. Aamir looks younger but talks a lot (on and off the screen), Madhavan and Sharman remains sidey for most of the movie part. Book's Karthik character is extended here as Chatur and it brings some genuine laughs.
The only original scene can be described with Mona Singh's delivery with vacuum cleaner...and yeah I liked it...(Finally something innovative) otherwise it's collection of really good forwards than you get on e-mail every now and then.
Inspiration isn't a bad thing ;-) and Again the movie is really good. But certainly all is not well.
No comments:
Post a Comment